FROM OUR BLOG: ARTICLES, OPINIONS, LEGAL TOPICS
Juvenile Criminal Records and Adult Expungement
I want to expunge my record, but will my juvenile conviction disqualify me?
A complicated area of law that comes up from time to time, deals with juvenile criminal records, and how they impact eligibility for adult sealing or expungement in Florida. I have been contacted by clients before, frustrated from calling different lawyers and getting the run-around. “No one seems to know the answer,” they’ll say. There are a few reasons for some common misunderstandings in this area of practice.
In general, the juvenile justice system seeks to rehabilitee young offenders, while the adult justice system seeks to punish.
For starters lets dispel a common misconception: there are no juvenile convictions, instead there is adjudication of delinquency. I know, I’m using ten-dollar words, but bear with me. To put it simply, an adult is “convicted” of a crime; a juvenile is “adjudicated delinquent” for committing a crime. Under Florida law, a juvenile adjudication is not a criminal conviction. Fla Stat. 985.35(6). Although—I hate to say it—they are sometimes treated the same. One way to understand this distinction is to understand the goals of these two systems. In general, the juvenile justice system seeks to rehabilitee young offenders, while the adult justice system seeks to punish. It therefore follows that the juvenile system does not wish to burden young offenders with all the attending consequences of a permanent criminal conviction.
First, let’s take a look at Florida Statutes. The following sections will guide us in assessing the viability of expungement in Florida.
Can the record be Expunged or Sealed?
Remember, under Fla Stat. 943.0585, we can expunge a criminal record if (and only if) we can clear a few hurdles. First, the charges must have been dropped, dismissed, abandoned, or the Defendant was found “not-guilty,” or acquitted.
If instead you had adjudication withheld, then you are looking at a court-ordered sealing, not an expungement. A court-ordered sealing—under Fla Stat. 943.059—is very similar to a court-ordered expungement with just a few tiny nuances. But remember, to determine eligibility for a sealing, we need to take an additional step. Section 943.0584 of the Florida Statutes, lays out a list of offenses that cannot be sealed, even if adjudication was withheld. The list can be found here. So, if the record you are seeking to seal is not on this list, you are okay.
Where the confusion lies:
Next, we must determine that we have not been previously convicted as an adult for any criminal offense in Florida, or adjudicated delinquent as a minor for a felony, or for certain listed misdemeanors. This section is where the confusion starts. On its face, it appears to say that if you have been adjudicated delinquent as a minor for any felony, or for certain misdemeanors, then you are ineligible. But, let’s take a closer look. Section 943.0585(1)(d) says as follows:
“The person has never, as of the date the application for a certificate of expunction is filed, been adjudicated guilty in this state of a criminal offense or been adjudicated delinquent in this state for committing any felony or any of the following misdemeanors, unless the record of such adjudication of delinquency has been expunged pursuant to s. 943.0515:”
In the last sentence, there is an exception. The statute—in summation—tells us that one cannot have a record expunged if they have an adjudication of delinquency for any felony or certain misdemeanors, unless the juvenile offense has been automatically expunged pursuant to Fla Stat. 943.0515.
So, let us assume (for the purpose of this article) that you did have a juvenile record. In fact, you were adjudicated delinquent for committing a felony. This doesn’t mean you are disqualified, if that offense was automatically expunged under section 943.0515. So what exactly is automatic expungement?
Let’s take a look.
The statute—in summation—tells us that one cannot have a record expunged if they have an adjudication of delinquency for any felony or certain misdemeanors, unless the juvenile offense has been automatically expunged pursuant to Fla Stat. 943.0515.
Fla Stat. 943.0515, lays out the mechanism for how juvenile records are automatically expunged in Florida. To summarize, your juvenile record will be automatically expunged at the age of 21. Or, if you were classified as a serious or habitual juvenile offender, or you were sentenced to serve time in a juvenile corrections facility, it will be automatically expunged at the age of 26.
There are, however, some exceptions to this general rule.
In summation, you can have a juvenile adjudication of delinquency on your record, and still qualify to expunge your adult record, as long as the juvenile record was automatically expunged. And remember, all juvenile records will be automatically expunged by the age of 26 (most at the age of 21) as long as you didn’t get charged with or convicted of a forcible felony after you turned 18 but before the automatic expungement occurred, or weren’t convicted as a minor of an adult forceable felony, or adjudicated delinquent for a sexual offense requiring sex offender registration. This means that most people with juvenile adjudications will be eligible. Which is good news!
The Law Office of William B. Wynne, P.L.L.C., provides expungement and sealing services throughout the entire state of Florida. If you would like to expunge or seal your criminal record, please call today for a free consultation. (813) 532-5057